Arize Phoenix and Opik are both open-source tracing and evaluation platforms for LLM and agent applications, and the first thing that separates them is the license, not the feature list. Phoenix is built on OpenTelemetry and ships under the Elastic License 2.0 (ELv2), which allows self-hosting for internal use but not resale as a hosted service. Opik ships under Apache-2.0 and bundles evaluation with automated prompt optimization. If you need permissive redistribution or plan to offer hosted observability, that points to Opik; if you want vendor-neutral tracing across a mixed stack, it points to Phoenix.

I also installed both Python packages side by side on my Apple M1, each in its own clean virtual environment. Phoenix 19.13.0 pulled in 148 packages and 571 MB of site-packages; Opik 2.2.13 pulled in 70 packages and 176 MB. Both imported cleanly, and each package's own license metadata matched its repository license. That measures the arize-phoenix and opik packages, not tracing throughput or a full self-hosted deployment.

Correction, September 22, 2026: the earlier package counts, timings, and combined size on this page did not match the saved run and have been replaced with the recorded values.

Arize Phoenix vs Opik at a glance

CriterionArize PhoenixOpik
LicenseElastic License 2.0 (ELv2)Apache-2.0
GitHub stars (2026-07-01)10.4k20.2k
Integrations25+ (OTel-based, framework agnostic)60+, plus native OTel support
Self-hostingDocker, Kubernetes, HelmDocker Compose, Kubernetes/Helm
Hosted optionapp.phoenix.arize.comComet.com managed cloud
Prompt/agent optimizationPlayground for manual testingBuilt-in Agent Optimizer, 6 algorithms
Coding assistantNot offered"Ollie" applies trace-derived fixes to code

What Arize Phoenix and Opik actually do

Arize Phoenix is an open-source AI observability and evaluation platform from Arize AI, the company that also sells a separate commercial observability platform. Phoenix captures traces of LLM and agent calls using OpenTelemetry, the vendor-neutral standard for instrumenting distributed systems, then adds LLM-powered evaluations, dataset versioning, and a prompt playground for testing changes before you ship them.

Opik is Comet's open-source observability and evaluation platform for LLM applications, RAG pipelines, and agentic workflows. It combines call tracing with LLM-as-a-judge evaluation (another LLM scores outputs against criteria such as hallucination or relevance), production monitoring, and an agent optimizer that iterates on prompts automatically.

Both solve the same problem: once an LLM app leaves a notebook, you need to see what the model actually did, catch regressions, and prove that a change improved quality. As Itamar Syn-Hershko wrote in BigDataBoutique's LLM observability comparison, "Retrofitting observability into a production LLM application is far harder than building it in from day one."

Licensing: Elastic License 2.0 vs Apache-2.0

Phoenix ships under the Elastic License 2.0. ELv2 lets you use, modify, and self-host the software, but it restricts offering it to third parties as a hosted service and bars circumventing license-key functionality. For a team running Phoenix internally, this rarely matters. For a vendor thinking about reselling observability as a managed product, it does. Phoenix's self-hosted core is free to use under those terms, and Arize also runs a hosted version at app.phoenix.arize.com with its own pricing, separate from the open-source library.

Opik ships under Apache-2.0, one of the most permissive licenses in open source, and an OSI-approved one. It places no restriction on commercial use, hosting, or redistribution and requires only that you preserve copyright and license notices. The repository is public, with over 500 releases as of mid-2026, and Comet also sells an enterprise tier with additional scale and support features. When procurement or legal review is part of the decision, this is the clearest difference: Opik has no license-key gate to negotiate around.

My read: if your company resells developer tooling or has a blanket policy against non-OSI-approved licenses, expect ELv2 to rule Phoenix out regardless of feature fit. If you are only instrumenting your own product, you are unlikely to run into the ELv2 restriction in practice.

Tracing depth: OTel-native Phoenix vs Opik's broader integrations

Phoenix's maintainers describe it as "vendor, language, and framework agnostic" because it is built directly on OpenTelemetry rather than adding OTel support after the fact. Any system already emitting OTel spans, not just LLM calls, can flow into Phoenix's trace viewer without a bespoke SDK. It supports 25+ frameworks directly, including OpenAI, Anthropic, LangGraph, LlamaIndex, CrewAI, and DSPy.

Opik takes the opposite path: broad, first-party integration coverage. It lists 60+ integrations, including OpenAI, Anthropic, LangChain, LlamaIndex, CrewAI, AutoGen, Google ADK, Mistral, Cohere, and Groq, and it added OpenTelemetry support alongside its native SDKs rather than building OTel-first.

What installing each package costs

I installed each package with uv pip install into its own fresh virtual environment, then counted installed packages, measured the size of site-packages, read the license field from the package metadata, and checked that the package imports.

MeasurementArize PhoenixOpik
Version resolved19.13.02.2.13
Packages installed14870
site-packages size571 MB176 MB
Install time223.8 s396.9 s
License field in package metadataElastic-2.0Apache 2.0 License
Imports cleanlyYesYes

The package count and disk footprint are the reproducible parts. Install time depends on network conditions during the run, so I would not treat the slower Opik install as a property of the package.

Evaluation and prompt optimization: where Opik pulls ahead

Both tools support LLM-as-a-judge evaluation, but Opik goes further into the optimization loop. According to Comet's Opik product page, its Agent Optimizer ships six algorithms that improve prompts and tool definitions against a scoring function, and its "Ollie" assistant reads traces, diagnoses the failure, and writes the fix into your codebase instead of only flagging the problem. Opik also ships Guardrails for content and PII policy enforcement, plus 30+ pre-built LLM-as-a-judge scoring metrics.

Phoenix's evaluation work centers on its Playground: a UI for comparing model outputs, replaying traced calls with different prompts, and running LLM-powered evals against datasets you version alongside the code. Phoenix added "PXI" (Phoenix Intelligence), an AI engineering agent aimed at debugging traces, but as of this writing it does not ship an automated prompt-optimization loop comparable to Opik's Agent Optimizer.

If your bottleneck is "we know evals are failing but tuning the prompt by hand is slow," Opik's optimizer addresses it directly. If your bottleneck is "we cannot see what our multi-framework agent stack is actually doing," Phoenix's OTel-native tracing is the more direct fix.

Self-hosting footprint and framework coverage

Both platforms are designed to be self-hosted, which matters when data residency or cost rules out sending every trace to a third-party SaaS. Opik splits its options by stage: Docker Compose for local development and Kubernetes with Helm for production scale, with the managed Comet.com tier as the alternative. Framework coverage tips toward Opik on raw count (60+ vs 25+), but Phoenix's OTel foundation narrows that gap in practice: it can ingest traces from anything emitting OTel spans even without a dedicated integration, which matters if you have already standardized on OpenTelemetry elsewhere in the stack.

Which should you pick

Pick Phoenix if you run several LLM frameworks side by side, already use OpenTelemetry for the rest of your infrastructure, and want tracing that stays vendor-neutral as the stack changes. Pick Opik if you want evaluation and prompt optimization in one tool, need a fully permissive Apache-2.0 license for procurement, or want a coding assistant that turns trace failures into code fixes.

The two are not mutually exclusive: teams that need both strengths often run one as the tracing backbone and lean on the other for its specific strength. If a third option is on your list, the Langfuse vs Opik comparison covers the closest adjacent decision.

A Phoenix versus Opik evaluation that avoids vendor scorecards

The top result for "Opik vs Phoenix" is Comet's comparison of its own product. Use it to find feature claims, then verify them in both projects' documentation and repositories. For a two-day proof of concept, trace the same agent run in both tools, attach one human-labeled failure case, run the same evaluation dataset, and export the trace plus scores. Record setup steps, data retention, self-hosting requirements, and the license that applies to the exact component you deploy. That tests the workflow you need instead of assuming a longer feature list means better observability.

FAQ

What is the difference between Langfuse and Phoenix?

Langfuse is MIT-licensed and framework-agnostic from inception, similar in spirit to Phoenix's OTel-native approach but under a more permissive license. Phoenix differentiates on its deep OpenTelemetry foundation and built-in prompt playground. The Langfuse vs Opik comparison shows how Langfuse stacks up against Opik specifically.

What is the difference between Phoenix and MLflow?

MLflow is primarily an ML experiment-tracking and model-registry tool that added LLM tracing later; Phoenix was built from the start for LLM and agent observability on top of OpenTelemetry. Teams already standardized on MLflow for classical ML often add Phoenix for LLM-call-level tracing rather than replacing MLflow outright.

How I tested this

  • Machine: Apple M1 (arm64, Darwin 26.3), Python 3.13.5.
  • Versions: uv pip install resolved arize-phoenix 19.13.0 and opik 2.2.13.
  • Date: August 2, 2026.
  • What was run: one install of each package into its own clean virtual environment, followed by a package count, a site-packages size measurement, a read of each package's declared license field, and an import check.
  • Not tested: tracing throughput, evaluation quality, the Agent Optimizer, the hosted products, or a full self-hosted server deployment. The feature, integration, and licensing comparison comes from each project's repository and Comet's product page, not from running those features.
  • Raw record: the public results file has every measurement and the machine details. It omits runtime logs and redacts local filesystem paths; the measurements are unchanged.

References